Conn Man's owens-laser crash stack (#35) was in his join.log -- and re-running
join.bat deleted it before it could be sent. The bat now rotates instead:
join.log -> join.old.log at launch. One generation of history, the exact
insurance that would have closed#35 tonight.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Regression in my own fix from an hour ago, reported immediately by the
operator on relaunch:
find: '/I': No such file or directory
find: 'btl4.exe': No such file or directory
The game has exited. ...
The wait loop called bare `find`, which resolves to the MSYS/Git-Bash **Unix**
find on any box with git on PATH (confirmed here: `which find` ->
/usr/bin/find, `which timeout` -> /usr/bin/timeout). So the loop errored out
and fell straight through -- restoring exactly the misleading "The game has
exited" message it was meant to remove. `timeout` was the same exposure one
line later (GNU coreutils ships one, with different arguments), so the block
had TWO PATH-dependent failures.
Harmless to the game (the loop only reports; it never touched the session),
but it made the fix a no-op for anyone with git installed -- which is every
developer and a fair number of players.
FIX: no external tools at all.
* detection is now a pure-cmd `for /f "tokens=1"` over tasklist output,
comparing the first token to btl4.exe -- no find/findstr;
* tasklist and timeout are both invoked by ABSOLUTE %SystemRoot%\System32
path, so a shadowing PATH cannot reach them.
Failure modes stay safe: if tasklist is unavailable the variable never gets
set and the loop degrades to reporting immediately (the old behaviour, never a
hang), and a genuinely dead exe still falls straight through so the #41 launch
forensics are untouched.
VERIFIED both branches by running the shipped detection lines from THIS bash
shell -- i.e. the hostile shadowed PATH that broke v1, a harder case than a
playtester's clean environment:
game running -> RESULT: WOULD-WAIT [process detected]
absent-name control -> RESULT: WOULD-EXIT [no process]
No find/timeout errors in either.
(players/ is the shipped source per tools/mkdist.py:78; the gitignored root
copies re-synced byte-identical.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator report while trying the build: the window said the game had exited
"with an error", yet the game loaded and played fine.
There was no error. The launchers were lying. The front end does NOT stay
resident: btl4console.cpp CreateProcessW()es the mission generation, closes
both handles and ExitProcess(0)s itself. So the bat's child exiting means
"the menu handed off", not "the game closed". All four launchers then
immediately printed
[.. ] btl4.exe exited with code 0
The game has exited. If it closed unexpectedly, send the operator ...
while the game was still loading in the handed-off process. Verified live on
the operator's own session: first process pid 33352 = MENU profile, handed off
to pid 12564 = GLASS profile, which was the one actually running; exit code 0
throughout. Harmless in itself, but it reads as a crash to a playtester and
would have generated false bug reports on a test night.
FIX: after the front-end child exits, poll until no btl4.exe remains, THEN
report. Applied to play_solo / join / join_lan / play_steam.
The #41 launch forensics are preserved: an exe that dies before it can run
leaves no process, so the wait falls straight through and launch_report.txt
still records timing, exit code and whether the log was ever created.
Verified the wait condition both ways against the live session (read-only, no
second instance spawned): btl4.exe present -> WOULD-WAIT; absent -> WOULD-EXIT.
NOTE for future edits: players/ is the SOURCE OF TRUTH (mkdist packages from
there, tools/mkdist.py:78); the root-level copies are gitignored local
conveniences AND were LF-only, while players/ is correctly CRLF. Since this
change adds a `goto` label -- the construct most likely to misbehave in an
LF-only bat -- the root copies have been re-synced byte-identical from
players/ so local runs match the shipped artifact.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
David's failures leave a 0-byte (or absent) join.log -- the exe can't
testify about a death before WinMain. The bats now bracket it from
OUTSIDE: launch_report.txt records the launch timestamp, the exe's
EXIT CODE (fingerprints the failure class: 0xC0000135 DLL-not-found,
0xC0000005 AV, AV-kill signatures, our clean exits), whether join.log
was ever created (never-created = blocked before our first
instruction), and its size. Verified with a synthetic -1073741819
exit. The 'exited' message now asks players to send BOTH files.
With this + the 507 first-breath line + the crash self-report, every
failure mode now leaves evidence somewhere: bat report (pre-WinMain),
first-breath (WinMain reached), [crash] stack (anything after).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Field 2026-07-23 (second night): a player's join.bat failed 3x in a row
with a 0-byte join.log -- indistinguishable from 'never ran'. Two
causes of evidence loss fixed:
1. The first flushed log line now happens the INSTANT the log opens
(version, pid, args, first-process vs relaunched-generation). An
empty log after this build means the exe was killed before WinMain
-- an external cause (antivirus/loader), not ours.
2. The menu->game relaunch chain truncated join.log each generation
(BT_LOG_APPEND was unset in the player bats): the crashed
generation's evidence was erased by the next attempt. The bats now
delete the log once per bat run and append across generations.
Also explains the confusing 'The game has exited' bat message on
SUCCESSFUL launches (the menu process exits after relaunching the game
detached) -- the log now records the whole chain.
The 1995 front-desk conversation, over the internet. join.bat/
join_lan.bat now open a JOIN-GAME menu (the FE in BT_FE_JOIN trim:
CALLSIGN edit + the 18-mech list + JOIN); the choice relaunches into the
normal join with BT_CALLSIGN/BT_MECH env, rides the relay SEAT_REQUEST
as {callsign NUL mech NUL} (empty payload = roster defaults, wire-
compatible), and the relay validates the mech tag, HOLDS egg delivery
until every pod's console pad is connected, rewrites the egg via
eggmodel (vehicle= + rasterized callsign bitmaps, graceful no-PySide6
fallback) and streams it to all pads -- so every player's egg copy
carries every player's callsign.
The hold is gated on CONSOLE-PAD count, not game-side registration: a
pod HELLOs only after parsing the egg's roster, so a registration gate
deadlocks (hit live in the first run; pods animate in WAITING FOR
MISSION ASSIGNMENT during the hold).
Verified 2-node e2e (env-injected requests): thor/vulture requested over
roster defaults bhk1/ava1 -> relay held 1/2, released at 2/2, rewrote
both seats (relay log), the delivered egg carries vehicle=thor/vulture +
name=VIPER/MONGOOSE, both pods launched and built [cyl] tables for both
requested mechs. Join-menu layout screenshot-verified; the menu's
click-through relaunch awaits live human verification.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The three build dirs (build\ pod, build-glass\, build-steam\) were compile-
time splits of the same game; the tax was real: a stale steam exe shipped 2
days behind, the felt keymap flipped with the boot flavor, and cockpit
clicks were silently dead in the pod build (the trigger-config incident).
Now everything compiles into the single build\ exe:
- CMakeLists: BT_GLASS/BT_STEAM options removed; the glass TUs (PadRIO,
bindings, panel, glass windows, plasma) + FE/console + Steam transport
compile unconditionally; both macros always defined (seam markers).
- Steam: steam_api.lib linked with /DELAYLOAD:steam_api.dll + delayimp --
the DLL maps only when SteamAPI is first called, and every call site
gates on BT_STEAM_NET=1 (BTSteamNet_* short-circuit on steamActive), so
machines without the DLL run everything but Steam sessions.
- CABINET GUARD (btl4main): the miniconsole menu previously claimed any
zero-arg launch -- unified, that would hijack the pod cabinet's boot
shape. The menu now requires BT_PLATFORM=glass (or BT_FE_MENU=1);
platform parse moved above the fe_menu_mode computation. A bare boot
behaves exactly like the old pod build (DEV profile, wait for egg).
- Bats (play_solo/join/join_lan/play_steam) + the btoperator.py template:
single build\ path + BT_PLATFORM=glass. mkdist: one exe (+DLL scan
picks up OpenAL32 + steam_api). build-glass\/build-steam\/build-glass2\
(a stale Jul-20 cache) deleted.
Verified matrix on the unified exe:
bare zero-arg boot == old pod exe (same DEV profile + egg-load path;
the segfault on a missing egg is pre-existing, baselined vs the zip exe)
glass + BT_BTNTEST scripted click -> [cfgmap] ENTER/EXIT (trigger config)
runs with steam_api.dll ABSENT (delay-load proven)
glass zero-arg -> miniconsole menu
2-node loopback MP: 145 ticks each, cross-connected
BT_STEAM_NET=1 without Steam client -> "staying on Winsock", game runs
KB: context/glass-cockpit.md compile-gates section rewritten for the
unified model.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
join.bat + join_lan.bat + the btoperator.py generator template now prefer
build-glass\Release\btl4.exe when present and set BT_PLATFORM=glass with it
-- so MP sessions on a dev checkout get PadRIO (mouse-clickable cockpit
buttons: trigger config, MFD banks, radar rails) and the bindings.txt keymap,
identical to solo play. Player zips (which ship only build\) fall back to
the pod build exactly as before.
Verified: 2-node loopback MP smoke on the GLASS build (the documented
procedure: A -egg MP.EGG -net 1501 + B -net 1601 + tools/btconsole.py) --
both nodes cross-connected (GameMachineHost 1502/1602), ~150 sim ticks
each, no errors. btoperator.py syntax-checked; regenerated bats carry the
same guard.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Field report: a remote player had smooth gameplay but in 3RD-PERSON with
NO gauges. Cause: view mode + gauges are CLIENT launch flags, not
something the relay/console can enforce -- and join.bat set neither, so
remote players booted in the game's desktop default (external camera, no
MFDs). The operator's own local launch sets both (the app's 'Start in
cockpit' + 'Dev gauges' checkboxes, on by default), which is why the
operator saw the correct view but remote players didn't.
The pod is a first-person cockpit with MFD gauges and no '3rd person' at
all, so cockpit is the right default for players. join.bat/join_lan.bat
now set BT_START_INSIDE=1 + BT_DEV_GAUGES=1. (Players can still press V
to toggle the external camera.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Field report: a remote player ran join.bat from the wrong place (inside
the zip, or the .bat separated from content\/build\) and got 'The system
cannot find the path specified' + dumps -- the relative 'cd %~dp0content'
failed cryptically.
Now each bat: cd to its own dir, verify build\Release\btl4.exe +
content\<egg> exist, else jump to :badpath and print a clear message
('this file must sit in the extracted folder next to content and build;
right-click the zip - Extract All and run it from there'). Verified: run
from a dir with no content/build -> the guidance prints, no dump.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two additions after the live-session troubleshooting:
1. LAUNCH-SHORT is now VISIBLE (btconsole). Pressing LAUNCH with an
empty roster seat previously did NOTHING (eggs_done_at only sets when
ALL seats ACK, so the manual-launch arming silently no-op'd -- the
'I pressed launch and nothing happened' confusion). Now the relay
logs 'LAUNCH pressed but NOT all seats are filled' + a per-seat
readiness line + a WARNING naming the empty seat(s) and the fix
(reduce the roster). When all seats DO fill it auto-arms (launch
request persists). Verified: 2/3 filled -> clear warning naming
seat3.
2. Friend logs are now retrievable (btoperator exporter). join.bat /
join_lan.bat set BT_LOG=join.log and their exit message tells the
player to send content\join.log to the operator if the game closed
unexpectedly -- closes the friend-side-crash blind spot (their log
was the generic btl4.log, un-named, easy to miss).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Field report (first internet-join attempt): both join bats 'hard
crash' on the remote machine. Root cause was procedural -- the host
session was not running -- but the failure PRESENTATION was the bug:
Release Fail() is a bare abort(), so a dead relay = silent process
death + instantly-closing console window.
- L4NET: the two player-facing dead-ends (LAN discovery no-answer,
seat request unreachable/full) now show a MessageBox saying what
happened and what to do before exiting (verified live against a
dead relay: 'BattleTech -- can't join the game' appears).
- join bats: echo + pause after exit so the window stays readable;
join_lan.bat header now says it is LAN-only (the remote user ran
both -- join_lan can never work over the internet).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A pod launched with no BT_SELF asks the relay for a seat before joining:
new control frames SEAT_REQUEST (-6) -> relay reserves the lowest roster
seat not claimed or reserved (60s reservation so simultaneous joiners
can't race onto one seat) -> SEAT_ASSIGN (-7, int32 hostID + NUL tag)
becomes relaySelf; everything downstream (egg self-match, HELLO) runs
exactly as if BT_SELF had been set. Roster full -> SEAT_FULL (-8) ->
clean Fail(). A real HELLO pops the reservation; a pod drop frees the
seat. Explicit BT_SELF still claims a specific seat (the operator's
local launches use it).
Client: L4NetworkManager::RelayRequestSeat (throwaway TCP dial to the
relay game port, 10s reply window). Relay: SEAT_REQUEST branch in
_handle_game_frame. Operator exporter collapsed from per-seat
join_as_playerN.bat to ONE universal join.bat (+ join_lan.bat with
BT_RELAY=auto) -- every player gets the same file, first come first
served, the arcade walk-up-to-a-pod model. players/ regenerated.
Verified: 8/8 seat stub tests (distinct seats in roster order, FULL on
exhaustion, claimed+reserved stays FULL, HELLO claim accepted, duplicate
HELLO refused); 2-node localhost e2e with NO BT_SELF on either pod ->
both seated, full ladder, RunMission pair, UDP flowing post-launch;
regression smoke: explicit-BT_SELF relay session clean with zero seat
requests, classic mesh (no BT_RELAY) un-regressed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
