arcattackandClaude Fable 5
bf87360c42
Answers "it's still there but invisible": not normal -- the real game removes
the dead entity (death row). Full entity teardown needs the mech render tree
unhooked from the renderer first (the remaining P5 follow-through), so until
then the burial transition makes the wreck behaviorally gone:
- collisionVolumeCount = 0 (the collision gather skips volume-less movers;
MoveCollisionVolume early-outs) -> no phantom blocking
- the player's target lock drops -> beams stop converging on / hitting the
empty spot, no phantom impact smoke
Verified: zero [damage] hits after burial; INERT fires one-shot at
"wreck buried".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
163 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
163 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
---
|
||
id: open-questions
|
||
title: "Open Questions — deferred systems, unknowns, get-from-Nick"
|
||
status: living
|
||
source_sections: "CLAUDE.md §9; docs/HARD_PROBLEMS.md; per-subsystem deferral notes"
|
||
related_topics: [source-completeness, subsystems, multiplayer, combat-damage, locomotion]
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
# Open Questions
|
||
|
||
Known unknowns + deliberately-deferred systems. For each: what's known, what's missing, what
|
||
would resolve it, status. Deferred ≠ broken — most are marked-and-guarded stand-ins with the
|
||
authentic path scoped.
|
||
|
||
## From Nick (external — gating for some paths)
|
||
- **[GATING] The BT game SOURCE CODE** — the missing implementation `.cpp` (mech, subsystems,
|
||
mapper, HUD, app; see [[source-completeness]]). Without it, Route A (recompile original) is
|
||
impossible; we reconstruct from the binary instead. Likely on a backup/dev drive. Status: OPEN.
|
||
- Confirmation the PodPC image is the complete content master. (Low priority — the runtime
|
||
`BTL4.RES` already has 8 maps + the full mech anim set.) Status: OPEN.
|
||
- Pod specifics for Phase 8: the 7-monitor driver setup, the RIO cockpit I/O protocol, current
|
||
Win10+wrapper pod config. Status: OPEN.
|
||
|
||
## Deferred subsystems / feeds (authentic path scoped, marked in code)
|
||
- **0xBD3 SubsystemMessageManager (WAVE 8)** — a per-mech **damage/explosion consolidation hub**
|
||
(`ConsolidateAndSendDamage` Performance @0049b784, `weaponExplosions` queue, `CommonDamageInformation`;
|
||
messmgr.hpp). ctor `FUN_0049bca4` (vtable 0x50b954, installs a Performance → ticks). The factory
|
||
caches it to **`Mech[0x10d]` = byte 0x434**. What wiring it needs: an untangle — our reconstruction
|
||
MISLABELED `Mech[0x10d]` as `controlsMapper` and `mech4`'s live drive reads it as the mapper, so the
|
||
real messmgr can't land there until the drive is re-pointed to the true mapper (**roster slot 0**,
|
||
installed by `SetMappingSubsystem`/`MakeViewpointEntity`; a `MechRIOMapper`). Payoff = authentic
|
||
damage/explosion consolidation (a COMBAT-fidelity improvement) + fixing the mapper/messmgr conflation.
|
||
⚠ **CORRECTION (verified 2026-07):** 0xBD3 does NOT gate the valve/Myomers/MessageBoard — those read a
|
||
DIFFERENT object at **`mech+0x190`** (both `FUN_004ac9c8` the valve guard `→+0x274` and `FUN_004ad7d4`
|
||
the Myomers gate `→+0x260` deref `owner+0x190`, which ≠ the 0x434 messmgr cache). The earlier
|
||
"0xBD3 gates 4 things" note was wrong.
|
||
- **✅ `mech+0x190` IDENTIFIED (2026-07): it is the owning `BTPlayer`** (`Mech::GetPlayerLink()`,
|
||
`MECH_OWNING_PLAYER`; ENTITY.h:430). Set by `FUN_0049f624` (the mech↔player bind: `mech+0x190 = player`
|
||
AND `player->playerVehicle(+0x1fc) = mech`), which resolves the player from the mission player registry
|
||
(`app+0x2c+0x54`, `FUN_0041fd18`) by the pilot key. The valve/Myomers "gates" read the owning player's
|
||
fields at `player+0x260` and `player+0x274` (the reconstruction maps this block as `showDamageReceived@0x25c
|
||
/ showKills@0x260 / showDamageInflicted@0x264 / roleClassIndex@0x274` in btplayer.hpp — from the SCORING
|
||
work, so the names may NOT match the gate semantics; the true meaning + the WRITER of `player+0x260/0x274`
|
||
are not yet pinned — part_013.c:4553-4660 is the TorsoSimulation, a different object, not the setter). So
|
||
there is NO new subsystem to build. **The wiring (small):** point `MechSubsystem::IsDamaged()` (`FUN_004ac9c8`, valve
|
||
guard) at `GetPlayerLink()->`(0x274) and `Myomers::OwnerAdvancedDamage()` (`FUN_004ad7d4`) at
|
||
`GetPlayerLink()->`(0x260) — via NAMED members (databinding trap: our BTPlayer layout ≠ binary; do NOT
|
||
raw-read `player+0x260`). ⚠ Resolve first: (a) a naming conflict — `FUN_004ad7d4` is labeled BOTH
|
||
`HeatModelActive` (heat.hpp) AND `OwnerAdvancedDamage` (myomers.cpp); re-verify which body is which; (b)
|
||
the true semantic of `player+0x260/0x274` vs the scoring-derived `showKills`/`roleClassIndex` names. NOTE:
|
||
these are MODE flags — in the basic test mission the inert Myomers / dormant valve is likely AUTHENTIC
|
||
(advanced damage off); wiring makes them RESPOND when a mission enables the mode, not necessarily change
|
||
the basic-mission behavior. The MessageBoard feed is separate (StatusMessagePool, below).
|
||
- **StatusMessagePool (NULL stub, btstubs.cpp:62)** — the per-player status-message queue.
|
||
BTPlayer+0x1dc is never populated → MessageBoard is empty (authentic for bring-up). What
|
||
resolves it: wire the pool + decode `AddStatusMessage @0042e580` + the `Player__StatusMessage`
|
||
record ({messageId@+0xc, nameEntity@+0x10}).
|
||
- **Gyroscope (0xBC4)** — layout + joint-I/O reconstructed, but the ctor field-init + the two
|
||
integrators (IntegrateEyeJoint @004b2ec0 / IntegrateBody @004b30ec) are incomplete → writes NaN
|
||
to the root joint. Reverted to a stub. A full subsystem-sim reconstruction (bigger than Torso).
|
||
- **MechControlsMapper look/eyepoint commit** — reconstructed but its offsets collide with declared
|
||
members; arbitrate before enabling (no port consumer yet). The fire-trigger-through-mapper is
|
||
still the `gBTWeaponTrigger` bring-up.
|
||
- **Myomers authentic coupling** — the structural un-stub is INERT (mover feed + heat-gen no-op).
|
||
Real coupling needs the advanced-damage gate (`OwnerAdvancedDamage`/`FUN_004ad7d4` → the owning
|
||
**BTPlayer** `mech+0x190`+0x260, NOT 0xBD3 — see the mech+0x190 item above) + `MoverAttach` routing
|
||
into the LIVE JointedMover (must be reconciled with the gait cutover first).
|
||
- **SeekVoltageGraph** — 4 Seek* attrs unpublished (a cluster-child, not config-called; non-blocking).
|
||
|
||
## Locomotion / combat polish (non-gating)
|
||
- Authentic per-mech TURN-RATE constant (currently a bring-up constant rate).
|
||
- Body-callback gimp handlers (states 16-19, targets 0x70b2/0x7161 undecoded → fall back to stand);
|
||
airborne callbacks (`FUN_004a6344`/`FUN_004a7970`).
|
||
- Wall-block-vs-climb tuning. **✅ Collision DAMAGE application — DONE 2026-07-08 [T2].** The two deferred
|
||
dispatches in `Mech::ProcessCollision` (mech4.cpp: mech-vs-mech `:15324-15358` + icon-crunch `:15369-15401`)
|
||
now fire: on a collision with another Mech or a CulturalIcon, an `Entity::TakeDamageMessage{zone==−1}` is
|
||
dispatched to the victim (via `BTDispatchCollisionDamage`, the engine ctor — same as the weapon path), and
|
||
STEP 6's cylinder table resolves the impact point → a zone on the receiver. Terrain (walls/hills) matches
|
||
neither branch → blocks without damage (faithful). Reachability is guaranteed (`Mover::ProcessCollisionList`
|
||
calls the **virtual** `ProcessCollision` → `Mech::ProcessCollision`); built + stable. The live dispatch
|
||
wasn't captured headlessly (the solo auto-walker never rammed a tree/mech), but the path is proven reachable
|
||
and composed of runtime-verified pieces. **Note:** validated STEP 6's height ref along the way —
|
||
`collisionTemplate->maxY ≈ 7.1` (a real mech height), confirming `CylinderReferenceHeight` reads a height,
|
||
not the heat value the `mech+0x2ec` dual-labeling (heat-gauge sink vs groundRef, mech4.cpp:2697) hinted at.
|
||
- **✅ Cylinder hit-location (STEP 6) — DONE + LIVE 2026-07-08 [T2].** Built + runtime-verified: the `dmgtable.cpp`
|
||
classes now have real storage + a working `ResolveHit→zone`, the mech ctor loads the type-0x1d table by the
|
||
DamageZoneStream name (`[cyl] table 'bhk1' layers=7`), and `Mech::TakeDamageMessageHandler` resolves
|
||
unaimed (zone==−1) hits before base-routing. ⚠ The FIRST "verified" claim was PARTIAL: the table was
|
||
cached via `Wword(0x111)` (the ABSORBER — stores nothing) so every unaimed hit silently no-op'd; fixed
|
||
2026-07-08 by promoting the cache to the named member `Mech::damageLookupTable`
|
||
([[reconstruction-gotchas]] §2). Now verified end-to-end (19 zones resolving, `BT_AUTOFIRE` harness).
|
||
Full change list in [[combat-damage]] "STEP 6 COMPLETE". Historical investigation notes retained
|
||
below for provenance.
|
||
**Re-investigated 2026-07 (see [[combat-damage]] for the full algorithm):** the table (height×angle
|
||
grid, resource type 0x1d) IS built (recon `StandingAnimation` @Mech[0x111], but with an EMPTY name → 0 rows,
|
||
because `ResourceFindByName` is a **no-op template stub**). **CORRECTION to the earlier note:** the LOOKUP is
|
||
**exported** [T1] — `FUN_0049eb54` (table height→row) + `FUN_0049e678` (row angle→cell), NOT unexported.
|
||
Only the thin `Mech::TakeDamageMessageHandler` glue (zone==-1 → call the lookup → `damageZones[zone]->TakeDamage`)
|
||
is unexported, and it's fully implied by pieces already reconstructed → no disassembly needed. Remaining:
|
||
6b real `FindByName` (name = the mech's type-0x14 DamageZoneStream name @ResourceDescription+0xc); 6c the 3
|
||
container ctors + the lookup as a `BTCylinderResolveZone` bridge (ground the cell zone-dict stream format vs
|
||
the real .RES bytes); 6d register the handler + verify. Feasible; the only open risk is the cell stream format.
|
||
The earlier-cited `FUN_004a0230`/`FUN_0049ed0c` don't exist.
|
||
- **Death sequence — CORE DONE 2026-07-08 [T2]; effects+anim deferred.** `Mech::UpdateDeathState()`
|
||
(mech4.cpp) reconstructs the death STATE machine (collapse `movementMode` → RP `VTV::DeathShutdown`
|
||
subsystem loop → settle to disabled/frozen; wreck stays, no crash) — runtime-verified (`BT_DEATH_LOG`).
|
||
Full map + citations in [[combat-damage]] "Death SEQUENCE". ✅ (b) `MechDeathHandler` DONE (mechdmg.cpp) +
|
||
✅ the render-side **RemakeEntity** destroyed-mesh swap DONE 2026-07-08 (btl4vid.cpp
|
||
`RemakeEntityRenderables` + `BTRemakeMechModel` bridge; in-place `SetDrawObj` swap — the tree dtor does
|
||
NOT cascade so never rebuild). ✅ (a) **RESOLVED — no collapse animation exists in BT 4.11** [T1]: the
|
||
fall latch (modes 5-8 → table slots 0x1c-0x1f) is a vestige — no loader fills the slots, no fall clip
|
||
ships, and firing it would bind resource 0 (an AUDIO stream) as keyframes. ✅ The authentic death
|
||
VISUAL is the **WRECK-HULK SWAP** (death ModelList `blhdead` → effect 104 → the victim becomes its
|
||
`<mech>dbr.bgf` burning hulk) — RECONSTRUCTED + verified (`SwapToWreck`, btl4vid.cpp; see
|
||
[[combat-damage]] "Death SEQUENCE" for the full chain + proofs).
|
||
✅ The wreck **sinks** (the 1996 quadratic burial, `offsetY = -0.025·t²`, gone ~17s) with the `ldbr`
|
||
debris field; at burial it goes **INERT** (collisionVolumeCount=0 + target lock dropped — no phantom
|
||
blocking/hits). **Remaining**: (c) the whole-mech **DeathSplash** radius damage; wreck mesh FLAMES
|
||
(flamesml/flamebig + sweep flicker, 1996 script case 4); the **full entity teardown at burial**
|
||
(the authentic death-row removal — needs the mech render tree unhooked from the renderer first;
|
||
the inert wreck is the safe stand-in until then).
|
||
Do NOT issue DestroyEntityMessage on death (before the render-tree teardown lands).
|
||
- **Critical-subsystem plugs UNBOUND (43 skips/mech) [T3].** `MechCriticalSubsystem::subsystemPlug`
|
||
never gets WIRED to its live subsystem (the ctor's Resolve() at mechdmg.cpp:276 only READS; the
|
||
binding write is elsewhere/unreconstructed), so `SendSubsystemDamage` skips every entry via the
|
||
unbound-plug guard (mechdmg.cpp, added 2026-07-08 after a live NULL-deref AV in
|
||
`SendSubsystemDamage+0x93` — the 1995 binary derefs unchecked because there every plug is bound).
|
||
Consequence: zone destruction does NOT yet propagate damage into carried subsystems (generator/
|
||
gyro failures etc.). Also latent there: `SubProxy2` raw-offset reads (databinding trap) once s≠0.
|
||
- **Two dead Wword comparison branches (multiplayer)**: `mech.cpp:1511` + `:1613` (replicant
|
||
leg-state/stability sync in ReadUpdateRecord) — always-false BTVal comparisons ([[reconstruction-gotchas]] §2);
|
||
needs slots 0xf/0x10 promoted to named members when P6 replication work resumes.
|
||
|
||
## Multiplayer (Phase 7 / P6)
|
||
- Cross-pod COMBAT (target a replicant + route damage to the owning master).
|
||
- Replicant GAIT animation (replicants don't animate joints yet — derive from replicated velocity).
|
||
- The pod-LAN config (real IPs, bare-IP pilot entries). The WinSock2 TCP stack (L4NET.CPP) is
|
||
reconstructed + smoke-tested on one box (two instances share a world, movement replicates).
|
||
|
||
## Rendering follow-ups (non-blocking)
|
||
- **.PFX effect-layer polish (deferred 2026-07-08; the layer itself is LIVE + verified).** The
|
||
reconstructed BT particle layer (L4VIDEO.cpp, see its banner) renders the authentic .PFX content
|
||
(fire + smoke, premultiplied blend, impact-frame oriented — weapon hits AND damage bands via
|
||
`lastInflictingID`, now written by `Mech::TakeDamageMessageHandler`). Remaining nuances, all
|
||
cosmetic: (a) `atten/attenv` distance attenuation not honoured; (b) the per-file texture name
|
||
(`btfx:firesmoke1_scr_tex`) — all effects share the radial-masked grit sheet; decoding FIRE.BSL
|
||
would give the authored sheet; (c) beams draw before particles, so a beam through thick smoke
|
||
reads too bright (pass-ordering); (d) `colorWarp/alphaWarp` applied as `t^(1/warp)` [T4 convention];
|
||
(e) emission uses rate×releasePeriod batching [T4 convention vs the exact 1995 emitter].
|
||
- Replacement-LOD selection for NON-additive multi-LOD models (needs the board's hot-spot/
|
||
reference-point semantics; leads: `s_dplobject.lod_ranges[16]/lod_hot_spot`, 0x2047/0x2048).
|
||
- Day/night MATERIAL path priority (BMF/IMG) — infrastructure done, gated `BT_MATPRI` (over-applies
|
||
to shared terrain mats); needs the terrain-material model understood.
|
||
- RGBA4444 alpha (TREE.BSL cutout) decoded but not alpha-tested outside punch batches; VTX/TGA paths.
|
||
|
||
## Content build sub-project (low priority)
|
||
- Lab/other-build maps (`des`/`burnt`/`frstrm`) are source-only (`.map` in CONTENT/BT/MAPS/); would
|
||
need compiling into a RES via the DOS `btl4tool.exe`. The 8 RES maps cover testing.
|
||
|
||
## Key Relationships
|
||
- Feeds from: every subsystem/render topic (their deferral notes collect here).
|
||
- Gating master: [[source-completeness]] (the missing BT source).
|